Down with recycling
There's currently a trend in the industry where companies are reusing old ideas. A few examples, coke and the kids singing on the rooftop ("I'd like to buy the world a coke/teach the world to chill), produced in the 60's. Alka Seltzer, "I can't believe I ate the whole thing", originally produced by Wells Rich Greene. Recently reshot, almost identically frame for frame, using "Ray's parents" from "Everyone Loves Raymond." From a strategic point of view, the advertisers were trying to tap into the nostalgic brand equity that these campaigns have. In a time of fickle client relationships, impossible deadlines, and exceedingly high expectations, I could see how strategically it would make sense to try to remind consumers why they love the brand in the first place by using campaigns that were successful in the past.
However, as a creative, I think it's a piss poor attempt at generating ideas by relabeling them. It's lazy and just isn't as good the second time around. We are killing ourselves everyday to come up with ground-breaking and innovative ideas. I can see how the pressure to produce a golden nugget could make someone so desperate that they use the archives as an emergency idea grab bag and present it as a decent, fresh concept. It's doing a disservice to themselves and the consumer. The original concepts don't even mean the same thing to a new generation. And when you become complacent (i.e. reshooting a commercial identically), there is no room for improvement and innovation. The only argument I can make for this trend is to push it further. If you take an old idea and turn it on its head, so it's executed even better than the original, yet relevant to your audience than I will throw a little support toward the idea of recycling. But other than that, come up with your own G-damn ideas.
However, as a creative, I think it's a piss poor attempt at generating ideas by relabeling them. It's lazy and just isn't as good the second time around. We are killing ourselves everyday to come up with ground-breaking and innovative ideas. I can see how the pressure to produce a golden nugget could make someone so desperate that they use the archives as an emergency idea grab bag and present it as a decent, fresh concept. It's doing a disservice to themselves and the consumer. The original concepts don't even mean the same thing to a new generation. And when you become complacent (i.e. reshooting a commercial identically), there is no room for improvement and innovation. The only argument I can make for this trend is to push it further. If you take an old idea and turn it on its head, so it's executed even better than the original, yet relevant to your audience than I will throw a little support toward the idea of recycling. But other than that, come up with your own G-damn ideas.
